When FiberTalk interviewed Michelle Agnew in March 2026, I decided to sign up for her 3D-Octopus goldwork online class. At the time, I couldn’t find any reviews of Michelle’s teaching. However, her website mentions that she is RSN-trained, has an academic degree and was made a Freeman of the Worshipful Company of Gold and Silver Wyre Drawers. Because her goldwork embroidery incorporates free-standing golden elements, I wanted to learn how she does it, as this technique is also used in late-medieval stumpwork embroidery but is poorly understood. At 500 GBP (€ 600 or $ 660) + postage + taxes, this online course isn’t exactly cheap. Note: If you don’t like negative reviews, consider this to be your trigger warning.

Michelle Agnew - 3D goldwork octopus on a grey linen background with a ruler
My version of Michelle Agnew’s 3D goldwork octopus

The information provided on Michelle Agnew’s website stated that the course would be taught in six live Zoom sessions of 2.5 hours each. The course would also include a full kit. It made no mention of a maximum number of students (I think there were about 20 at the first lesson) or any additional software being used.

A couple of weeks before the first class, I got an email from Michelle Agnew saying my kit had shipped. This was the point of no return, as Michelle does not allow for refunds after your kit has shipped. This email also mentioned an optional WhatsApp group. She also sent a PDF with the line drawings of the design. My kit arrived without any issues. It included a small, cheap wooden embroidery hoop. Luckily, the email stated that we could also use a frame. To me, that’s a much better choice for heavy goldwork embroidery. To frame my small slate frame, I had to provide my own piece of calico, since the piece in the kit was far too small.

Michelle Agnew - 3D goldwork octopus on a grey linen background

Further red flags appeared during the first Zoom class with Michelle Agnew. She was teaching this course for the fourth time. Still, the line drawing she provided had a mistake. It also became clear that the 17 spangles provided in my kit were not nearly enough compared with the picture on Michelle’s website. When I emailed Michelle, she told me not to use the picture on her website as a reference. I should only consult her actual Zoom teaching. As she never completed her own homework, we only ever saw bits of the octopus and thus never had a complete octopus for reference. Michelle does not provide any handouts. The Zoom recording (downloadable) is the only instruction you get.

Michelle Agnew - 3D goldwork octopus on a grey linen background

It also became clear that the WhatsApp group was used as a teaching aid. Michelle Agnew shared close-up pictures for reference. As I have privacy concerns regarding using Meta apps and don’t want to share my phone number with a bunch of strangers, I don’t use WhatsApp. When I asked Michelle to share the pictures with me via email, I got a flat no. She maintained that she did not use the app as a teaching aid and therefore saw no need to disclose this on her website. Besides, she told me that I knew about WhatsApp before the course started, as she disclosed its optional use in the email she sends when your kit ships (the point of no return). When I asked if I could send progress pictures via email, she warned me that she does not reply to email promptly. That turned out to be true. I had to wait up to four days. Not ideal when you need to finish a lot of homework within the week in time for the next lesson. One time, I didn’t receive feedback before the next lesson and ended up with a minor mistake that couldn’t be easily fixed.

As said, this online course comes with a full kit. However, the amounts were not calculated correctly. Not only did the kit not include a large enough piece of calico to use with a small slate frame, but it also didn’t have enough padding thread. Two very, very cheap components. As mentioned before, my kit did not come with enough spangles (again: cheap stuff – 50 gr (that’s 1000s) of 3mm gilt spangles sets you back a whopping € 5.65!). I also ran out of Rococco thread, something we were told was “a bit more dear”. By contrast, my kit contains so much smooth purl that I can probably make another five octopuses. I am a frugal stitcher; if I run out, most others will do too. The quality of some of the kit materials wasn’t fantastic either. For those of you not familiar with the prices of goldwork materials: the full kit is only a fraction of that 500 GBP. Michelle Agnew never responded to any of my concerns regarding the materials provided. One other student was told to get additional supplies from a craft store.

To summarise my experience with Michelle Agnew’s online teaching: I reasonably succeeded, as I am a very experienced goldwork embroiderer with a large stash of goldwork materials. I could troubleshoot and provide additional materials, or swap poor-quality materials altogether. When you price your online embroidery class as Michelle did, students should expect premium materials in sufficient amounts, course documentation alongside the live teaching and a teacher on hand for timely feedback.

P.S. I discussed my experiences with this course by Michelle Agnew with my Stitch & Chat group. Most felt that 500 GBP for an online course is too much to begin with. I was specifically asked to publish this review, as some had been on the fence about joining. I don’t like writing negative reviews as they come at a cost. Some readers will feel the need to let me know how outrageous and unfair my review is. It takes guts and duck skin to write them anyway. And please remember, I gave Michelle feedback several times, right from the start. None of my issues was taken seriously or solved.


0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder